Connect with us

Movie Reviews

A Ciambra



Reviewer: Marion Donnellier

Director: Jonas Carpignano

Stars: Pio Amato, Koudous Seihon, Damiano Amato

Released: 6th April 2018 (UK)

Jonas Carpignano’s second feature A Ciambra was praised all around international film festivals in the last few months. It even brought home the Europa Cinemas Label Awards at last year’s Cannes film festival.  Bringing back many protagonists from his previous feature Mediterranea, with A Ciambra Carpignano takes us to a small village in Calabria where Romani, Italian and African immigrants communities cohabit.

In the small Romani community of Ciambra, 14 years old Pio is desperate to grow up. The film starts us off with groups of young children, running around Pio and along the village streets, smoking. But Pio’s attention quickly shifts to his older brother, Cosimo, whom he follows everywhere.  When his brother gets arrested along with his father, Pio is determined to find a way to provide for his family the same way his brother did, through thefts and petty crimes.  Pio’s goal is clear but his young age rapidly becomes an obstacle.

Pio makes several attempts but fails.  To help his mother pay the 9000 Euros she owes for electricity, Pio steals suitcases from a stationary train but only gets 50 Euros from a stolen Ipad.

With Mediterranea, Carpignano made a plunge into the European refugee crisis while A Ciambra is more focused on the importance of family and the struggle of growing up. The representation of all different communities is rather used to isolate Pio who seems to be the only one navigating freely within all these differences.

From the start all young protagonists behave as adults would and yet the film overflows with youthful energy. Using real participants from the local community may have had something to do with it. The child’s point of view is emphasized with pop music and vivid colors. The camera moves the same way the children behave, in quick and uncoordinated movements. Carpignano explained that he used pop music to bring the audience closer to Pio. It is a “common denominator”. No matter where we are and what language we speak, “when the beat drops on a song that everyone knows, everyone is suddenly on the same wavelength”.

Pio is surrounded by love and warmth, which only adds to how important family is to him. His mother is the one Pio always turns to for recognition and she always returns the sentiment. But the central relationship seems to be between Pio and Ayiva. Although not related, both Pio and Ayiva share the same determination to provide for their family. Pio’s brother is more of an antagonist, either dismissing Pio or getting him in trouble, while Ayiva cares for Pio and welcomes him in his community.

Pio is an ambivalent character, stuck in between two ages. Resolved to help out his family by any means, he often depends on Ayiva and his motorbike to get around as the speed of trains terrifies him.

Family is strong in Pio but it is not always the one within your own community. When Pio is caught stealing from a friend of his own family, he is banished by his father. Ayiva’s community is the first place Pio looks for shelter, which makes it difficult for Pio when his brother asks him to betray Ayiva for money. Pio struggles but is still incapable of making a decision and so simply does not.

On of the most emotional scene comes towards the end when, still banished from his community, his sister comes to find him. Together they get on a train to steal more suitcases. This time Pio does not get out before the train starts and gets stuck on a moving train that he cannot control.  With the help of his sister the panic goes away.

A Ciambra does start off slowly and the first half of the story is used to establish Pio’s surroundings and the obvious obstacle he faces.  But if you commit you will be nicely surprised. Right at the middle of the film Carpignano inserts magical dream sequences during which Pio comes across visitors from the past. Curious, like most children are, Pio follows.  A reminder that, up until the end and despite Pio’s many attempts, everything in the film points to the fact that Pio is still a child.

But the solution becomes clearer and brings us to the end. After letting go of his juvenile fears, Pio follows his brother to a brothel. The film ends at a crossroad. Pio needs to make a final decision on his own. It is not the ending we wanted (or at least not the one I wanted) but it is definitely the one that Pio needs. The film leaves us hopeful and optimistic that Pio will finally be there for his family the way he wants to be.

There is a warm and youthful energy in A Ciambra that never quite leaves you. Pio is very charming character, whose loving dedication always forgives his childish flaws. It is an emotional coming of age story full of enchanting surprises.

London based Writer/Director moonlighting as film reviewer. If Holly Golightly and Margot Tenenbaum ever had a daughter, she'd make more sense than me. Indie film advocate. Always.

Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Movie Reviews

LFF Review 2018 – Madeline’s Madeline ★★★★



Madelines Madeline Movie Marker

Director: Josephine Decker

Stars: Miranda July, Molly Parker, Helena Howard

Released: London Film Festival

Indie favourite actress/director, Josephine Decker premiered her third feature, Madeline’s Madeline at Sundance earlier this year where she received praise for her unconventional take on mental illness.

16 years old Madeline suffers from unspecified mental health problems which have created a wedge between her and her slightly over bearing mother (Miranda July). Spending most of her time alone, she finds comfort when joining an experimental theatre troupe and even develops a strong bond with its ambitious director, Evangeline (the psychotic Molly Parker). When Evangeline starts to use Madeline’s delicate mental state and personal issues with her mother as part of her play, the line between reality and illusion quickly starts to blur.

‘The emotions you are having are not your own. They are someone else’s. You are not the cat – you are inside the cat’. So begins 15 minutes of blurred and beautifully shot sequence that immediately puts the audience in a state of daze. When we are officially introduced to Madeline, we find an energetic young woman who would much rather disappear behind wild animals in theatre rehearsals than have any serious discussion with her mother. Sharing the screen is the interesting Evangeline, who is as passionate as inspiring but whose play doesn’t seem to make much sense to anyone, including herself.

The film’s stand out is the acting and nothing ever feels rehearsed. Helena Howard as Madeline is terrific and easily switches between the disturbed teenager, the cat, the seductress, the turtle and the actress, always bursting with energy and vulnerability.

The film has its witty moments, particularly when during an acting exercise Madeline decides to punish Evangeline for using her personal confessions by simulating a painful childbirth, in the hopes of terrifying the freshly pregnant teacher.

Decker also explores the interesting duality of the role of the artist. Often torn between the idea that creating is disappearing behind someone’s else story or on the contrary it is all about using real experiences to bring depth and authenticity, Decker seems to suggest it is a little of both and that both extremes could end up with either an artificial or violating result. No one understands what Evangeline’s play is about at first and when she finally finds substance that speaks to others (Madeline’s personal issues), she chooses to entirely focus on it instead of adding her own substance and ends up being kicked out by the troupe.

Madeline’s Madeline is visually stunning thanks to Ashley Connor ‘s imaginative cinematography and both Howard and Decker bring to life a condition that is still misunderstood and dismissed. The storyline does takes its time to emerge and the daze occasionally mixes with confusion. Howard keeps the audience in her mental maze throughout the film. It is messy, unusual and dense and maybe that was the whole point.

Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

LFF 2018 Review – A Private War ★★★



A Private War Movie Marker

Director: Matthew Heineman

Stars: Rosamund Pike, Jamie Dornan, Stanley Tucci, Tom Hollander

Released: London Film Festival 2018

‘ I see it so you don’t have to!’ Rosamund Pike, as war correspondent Marie Colvin, spits out at her Sunday Times editor Sean Ryan (Tom Hollander) towards the end of A Private War  as they argue on the banks of the Thames which rolls serenely past. She means the atrocities of war which she is compelled to return to time and again to report on despite hating her own compulsion. She does it, she believes, to give a voice to the ordinary men, women and children who are fodder for the military and political ambitions of dictators and leaders themselves safe in their palaces, well, until the mob gets to them and takes selfies with their mutilated corpse as we see later in the film.

Marie Colvin was a much celebrated war reporter who was killed in Syria in 2012 along with her interpreter/guide. She achieved fame in her lifetime for her fearless, uncompromising journalism but also for the black eye patch she wore after losing an eye in Sri Lanka when reporting on the Tamil Tigers in 2001. Her death will still be fresh in the minds of those who follow current affairs as will her extraordinary persona.

It’s a testament then to the tremendous power of Rosamund Pike’s performance that minutes into A Private War she becomes Colvin. The deep gravelly voice, the Long Island accent, the no nonsense, blunt manner of speaking are not only completely captured but taken possession of by the very English rose Pike.

She embodies Colvin with a natural ease which exposes the private vulnerabilities of a woman who could have been simplistically portrayed as a one of those annoying ‘strong, uncompromising women’ that Hollywood seems to think raises the female profile but real women find unbearable. Pike is not afraid to make the chain smoking, heavy drinking, conflicted Colvin unlikable at times. But it’s in the quiet, reflective moments of Colvin’s life when she is alone with her ravaged eye and light desire for the normal suburban life she rejected that Pike is at her most effective. This is a film about the psychological damage of seeing what the rest of us don’t have to as much as it is about the grotesque mess of war on the battlefield.

Colvin wants a child and considers it with the man (Greg Wise) she’s already divorced a couple of times despite having suffered two miscarriages. She may or may not be prone to seeking connection through other convenient liaisons. Her friend tells her she’s an alcoholic and she thinks about convincing a psychiatrist she’s sane so she can leave a rehab clinic she’s an inpatient in before she’s really up to it. She’s plagued by flashbacks and nightmares.
We learn all this about her but, like her, don’t have time to fully process any of it before she and we are whisked off to Iraq. There she meets a freelance photographer, Paul Conroy, (Jamie Dornan – Fifty Shades Freed) and the two quickly form a professional partnership with Colvin very much in the driving seat as to where they go and what risks they take. In one case this involves her confidently flashing a gym membership card to get through a heavily armed checkpoint. The friendship which builds between the two is not explored enough and Dornan is not given enough to do but when the inevitable danger which is foreshadowed throughout the film befalls them it’s intense and a swallow-hard moment.

Even though we know her death is coming , when it actually does, there’s a real sense of loss, largely due to Pike having brought Colvin to life so brilliantly beforehand. I predict we’ll be seeing a lot of Rosamund Pike during awards season for this timely film produced by Charlize Theron about a very modern heroine.

Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

LFF 2018 Review – Assassination Nation ★★★★



Assassination Nation Movie Marker

Director: Sam Levinson

Stars: Odessa Young, Hari Nef, Suki Waterhouse

Released: London Film Festival 2018

When Director, Sam Levinson started writing Assassination Nation over two years ago, he probably had no idea how shockingly relevant this dark comedy would be today. Written as his wife was about to give birth, he credits his fear of raising his child in an increasingly brutal country as the main inspiration behind this vivid satire, depicting the disastrous consequences of living online.

The city of Salem, Massachusetts is about to delve into chaos when a data hacker starts exposing highly porn-ified secrets of its population. Internet search history, digital photos and texts conversations are published. Political careers and marriages end. The hack reaches Salem’s high school whose principal is also targeted and forced to resign, despite claiming his innocence. In need of a scapegoat, the town’s authority (macho detective and police man) finds it in high school head girl, Lily (Odessa Young), whose affair with a married man,  just leaked. Lily and her friends must face the town’s growing hysteria that quickly turns into a blood bath of sexism and brutality.

The film’s core storyline revolves around Lily, who with her friends make up the popular clique of Salem’s High School. The 1990’s had their mysterious virgin nymphs (“Virgin Suicide”) and the 2000s, their bullying princesses (“Mean Girl”) but in 2018, the popular girls are fun, clever and most of all, nasty. Born in a comfortable middle class family, Lily has good grades and a cheeky talent for drawing. What Lily and her friend lack is a reliable grown up figure to look up to. Surrounded by threatening boyfriends and denigrating parents, the only grown-up who pays her some attention is her principal but even he cannot completely give in when she makes a clever accusation of the sexism of internet and social media while defending her pornographic art work.

Assassination Nation 2 Movie Marker

There is thin line between victim and executioner in Assassination Nation and Levinson strategically jumps from teasing to threats as if one didn’t exist without the other. Levinson seems less interested in exposing the already well established outcomes of the digital age than exploring the hypocrisy and shaming young people, and particularly young woman, face on a daily basis.

Half way between  Little Red Riding Hood and Nikita, and far from victims, these girls fight back with whatever they are threaten with, usually guns but at times razors and even a shovel. Full of extreme close-ups, the camera is intrusive, and if this closeness can be difficult at first, it quickly helps creates a real connection with those girls.  Surrounded by obvious and familiar characters (naïve head cheerleader, immature boyfriend, cheating husband…), and lifted by invigorating performances by Hari Nef (Bex) and Odessa Young (Lily), these girls can only shine in authenticity and it is hard not to root for them.

Salem’s utter obliviousness takes final form in the slushy sipping little brother, revealed as the hacker. Youngest and quiet, he seemed like a harmless addition to the dinner table and yet could bring a nation to its knee. The warning signs were there, adults chose to ignore them. The film ends with a public letter to a certain president of a certain powerful nation and a feminist call to action against any form of violence and misogyny.

The film will most likely not affect every generation in the same way and will probably swing between anti-sexist fantasy revenge to painfully relevant. Yet there is nothing in this film that can’t be traced back to a recent newspaper headline or twitter feed, regrouped to create a bloody picture of the modern America, kids are made to grow up in.

“Don’t take your anger out on me, I just got here.”

Continue Reading